How to Get the Most from a Testimonial

I’m a big fan of user reviews.  As a consumer, I refer to them whenever they’re available, and I find that they influence my purchase decisions.

Short of a product demonstration, as an instrument of persuasion, the user review has to be among the most effective tools we have at our disposal.

Consider for a moment the difference in your own mind between a user review and its big brother, the testimonial.

As similar as I suppose they are in theory, I regard these two very differently.

To me the very designation – testimonial – suggests that the message will be positive… one notch down from its slippery sibling, the endorsement.

Particularly online, the testimonial has been so abused, bastardized and corrupted that unless they are particularly well presented, I find that I view them all as counterfeit… sales copy from deceptive marketers.

User reviews on the other hand, at least for now, remain relatively pure in my mind.

For some reason, I feel like the user review is a more authentic, unscripted expression of a real person’s real-life experience with a product or service.  Probably naively, I expect to hear both the good and the bad.

I trust them more.

So what do if you’re a testimonial junkie and don’t yet have the facilities to cultivate and display user reviews?

First and foremost, make sure that your testimonials are believable.  Lest you be lumped in with the counterfeiters.

To maximize the believability of your testimonials…

First, with the exception of spelling errors, embarrassing grammatical problems, and elimination of clichés, don’t edit them. People can spot a fake from a mile away, and if your testimonials are deemed as fakes, you’ve done yourself more harm than good.

Second, make sure they are specific. Speaking in generalities is neither authentic nor persuasive. Don’t present “Your service was great!”  That doesn’t mean anything to anyone.  Rather, favor testimonials with a real story.

“I arrived late and starving. I had to be in meeting with one of my biggest clients in one hour and had considered dashing through McDonalds on my way.  I was thrilled when I left the clean and peaceful setting of your restaurant having had one of the best bowls of French onion soup I’ve ever had… in 27 minutes flat! I’ll be back.”

Third, attribute your testimonials as specifically as you can. Why do marketers replace the name of the testifier with their state of residence?

Is it because the person giving the testimonial insists on remaining anonymous?  If they were so worried about their anonymity, why did they write this testimonial in the first place?  Did they really say, I’ll give you this testimonial, but you had better not say who wrote it?

I doubt it.  And unless your product pertains to hemorrhoids of some sexual dysfunction, no one else is going to buy it either. So at the very least, present a first name, last initial, city, state, and if relevant, a description of the person or their circumstances that make the testimonial valuable.

If you’re selling washing machines, an attribution like this might be appropriate.

Michelle B., Richmond, VA

Mother of five boys, ages 2 to 13

In certain circumstances, you could go even further to build believability with photos (before and after using your product if appropriate).

The second thing you have to do is make sure your testimonials serve their persuasive purpose.

Anytime we find ourselves quoting customers, the underlying purpose is most likely to remove the perception of risk and/or address a specific objection in the mind of the buyer. So, you want to be sure that your testimonials address actual fears or objections.

Holly Buchanan (a friend of mine and persuasion guru from FutureNow) wrote a wonderful post discussing the three traits of strong testimonials.  In discussing this point, she writes that “testimonials from skeptics stand out because they sound credible.”

Consider the following:

“I have been repeatedly disappointed after buying ____ because despite claims to the contrary, they’re always hard to assemble. So when I read that yours were quick and easy, I had my doubts. I’m now convinced. I assembled my ____ without tools in 3 stress-free minutes.”

In this case, the testimonial overcomes a common concern over assembly by acknowledging up front the legitimacy of this issue for other prospects – then dispensing with it.

This leads to Holly’s next point which is that your testimonials must be well-placed – making sure that the subject matter that is addressed in the testimonial relates to the information around it. Context is critical.

She also makes the insightful observation that there are really two types of relevance to consider.  The first (and most obvious) has to do with subject matter relevance. Place your easy-assembly testimonial near your claim that your product is easy to assemble.

The more subtle issue to consider however is your prospects stage in the buying cycle. On your landing page for example, your testimonials should be geared to a prospect who is still asking the more fundamental questions. How are different from other competitors? Can you fill my needs? What kind of company is this?

Testimonials dealing with the efficiency of your fulfillment and return processes are better aimed at people further along the buying cycle.

We all know this to be true.  The voice of a real customer… speaking candidly on your behalf can be extraordinarily powerful.  Your job is to see that it is projected, heard and believed at the right time and in the right place to move your prospects to action.